9 Ways To Make A Homemade Butt Plug + Makeshift Plugs

Making a homemade butt plug is not the safest way to enhance your sex life. But if you’re willing to experiment, your best bet would be to use a silicone mold and shape one this way.

Homemade Butt Plug

Butt plugs are one of the most popular sex toys and not without reason (see our Lovense Hush review if you want to know what the fuss is about).

They’re a great way to enhance your sexual experiences, and they’re fairly easy to use even for beginners.

But good ones can be fairly expensive, and there is also the issue with discreetness…

So you might be thinking about taking the DIY route and making one yourself, right?

Well, then before you try making a homemade butt plug, I recommend reading this post as I’ll cover everything there is you need to know about it!

Let’s jump in:

Dangers & Safety Precautions of Homemade Or Household Items

Now, let’s talk about safety first. 

In general, out of all the sex toys you can make at home, butt plugs are considered to be quite dangerous to DIY. 

This is mostly due to the very high possibility of your homemade butt plug getting lost inside your anus, and then you need to visit the ER…

And that’s what you want to avoid as it’s no fun having to explain how that piece of cucumber ended up inside your ass, right?

As someone who works in emergency medicine – I’ve seen too many incidents of patients with various things lodged in their rectum from DIY anal plugs or unconventional anal toys in general…Please, unless you’re a skilled glass or metal worker, just invest in a proper implement, less than 20 USD even at most shops.

You can find cheaply priced silicon plugs on Amazon, or AliExpress (mind the reviews) that are legitimate, quality silicon. (There’s even glass or stainless steel options for decent prices)

Source Reddit User JxKrovyu

You really might be better off just buying a very cheap and simple butt plug off Lovehoney or Shevibe.

Both sites have good quality cheap silicone butt plugs, and you can even find some affordable glass or stainless steel options. 

Also, when you’re buying from those websites, you don’t have to worry about privacy – both websites offer very discreet shipping, so no one will know what you’re ordering!

If you’re still thinking about making your own butt plugs, then you have to make sure that it won’t get lost inside you. 

You either need to make a butt plug that has a flange or a crosspiece at the base that is sturdy enough and won’t break off while using. 

How To Make A Butt Plug At Home

How To Make A Butt Plug At Home

OK, so now let’s talk about a few different ways you can get DIY a butt plug.

#1: Buy An Actual Butt Plug For $10-$20

Tracey Cox Supersex

The #1 option for you would be just to go and buy the best butt plug that was made specifically for that use.

It’s going to be way cheaper to buy one for $20 than ending up with an ER bill if you don’t have a wide enough base or a strong enough material, and your butt plug gets lost in your anus. 

Here are a few of the best options (& cheapest) that are great:

  • Tracey Cox Beginner Butt Plug – $10, get yours here.
  • Luxe Plug – $10, get it here.
  • CLOUD 9 GEMS – $10, get one here
  • Anal Beads by Calexotics – $10, get it here

As you can see, there are plenty of great options for less than $10, and it’s so much safer this way!

#2: Buy A Sanitary Silicone & Make Your Own Shape

Clone-A-Willy Molding Kit

Probably the best option if you still want to take the DIY route, would be to make your butt plug from silicone. 

It’s not that hard to do, and the material is safe to use. Also, it’s nonporous, so your homemade butt plug is not going to smell bad. 

And if it still looks intimidating, I recommend getting this Clone A Willy kit that will make the process so much easier. 

Now, originally it’s intended for creating a silicone dildo, but you can create any shape you want with it, so it works great for a homemade butt plug. 

You can grab the kit here on Lovehoney.

#3: If You Have Glass Blowing Skills…

Listen, if you’re somehow a talented glass blower, it might be useful to use your skills and create a glass butt plug for yourself. 

Glass but plugs are one of the best ones on the market, and they’re pretty safe to use. 

Also, they don’t get the smell and are extremely easy to clean, so it’s a win-win situation!

Of course, before you go on and create something, make sure that it has the flat base, which won’t let the butt plug slip inside your anus during use. 

#4: Make Use Of Your Woodworking Skills

Or maybe you’re not a good glassblower, but are a skilled woodworker?

You can use your woodworking skills to create a butt plug as well!

It won’t be as great as silicone or glass one, but it’s still good enough. 

If you decide to make a homemade butt plug out of wood, make sure that you choose a strong wood like oak or pine. 

Also, polish the butt plug very well as you don’t want to get splinters in your anus while using it!

Use a finishing varnish to ensure that everything is sealed and if you still doubt whether it’s safe to insert a piece of wood up your ass, use a condom with it. 

Makeshift Butt Plug Ideas: Things You Have At Home You Can Use

Makeshift Butt Plug Ideas: Things You Have At Home You Can Use

So, we’ve discussed some more advanced homemade butt plug options and now, let’s talk about some lazier options. 

I know that not everyone has the patience to play around with silicone or have talents for woodworking. 

The great news is that you don’t need any skills, and you can find a lot of things at home that you can use as a butt plug. 

#1: Try A Finger

The easiest and most straight forward way is to just simply use your finger. 

Seriously, it’s the safest and easiest option, and I think it’s way better than sticking some other things up your ass. 

You can try inserting one or multiple fingers and using different techniques to massage your anus for ultimate pleasure. 

#2: Or A Toothbrush

Now, if your fingers are not enough for you, then maybe using a toothbrush as a homemade butt plug will interest you. 

It won’t get lost very easily as it’s long, and there is the bristle part which should help you keep it stable enough. 

However, because it’s long and thin, it can tear inside your anus, so you have to be careful with that. 

If you’re feeling adventurous, I recommend using your electric toothbrush for some extra vibrations and pleasure. 

#3: Vegetable A Day Keeps A Doctor Away

Have some veggies lying around the house and no butt plug? 

Well then, try using carrots or cucumbers or even a banana with a condom as a butt plug. 

It might be a bit hard on your anus, so don’t forget to warm up and use lots of lube.

And, I don’t recommend making a stew out of those veggies you use for anal play after you’re done…

#3: Make One Out Of A Ginger Root

If you’re feeling extra naughty, you might want to try using ginger root to make your homemade butt plug. 

Yes, you read that right:

Ginger root can be used as a butt plug. 

There is even a term for that – frigging!

Now, historically it’s been used as a punishment, but now it’s a very popular sexual play when you insert a piece of ginger in the anus for that extra spicy experience. 

Simply get a root of ginger and carve it into a butt plug shape. Leave a wider base so that it won’t get lost so easily and enjoy the sensation!

#4: Candles Are For More Than Setting The Mood

Another idea is to use a candle with a condom. 

Get the candle of your desired shape and size. Then, put it inside very hot water so that the wax is easier to manipulate. 

Then, shape the candle a bit to remove shart corners and create a more pleasant shape. 

And then put on a condom before inserting it in your anus.


#5: Umbrella Handle

Now, if you have an umbrella at home that’s broken, take its handle and turn it into a butt plug. 

It will need a bit of skill to remove it from the metal pole, and then you’ll need to find something to add that will serve as a handle, but it’s totally doable!

Other People Tips, Experiences & Techniques

Now, let’s take a look at what other people are sharing online about their experiences with homemade butt plugs:

If you are a skilled woodworker you can fashion one with a ton of hard labour, it’s best to use a non-compressable material and make sure the anchor at the end is big enough to avoid loss…unless you know what you are doing you are just asking for an embarrassing trip to the emergency room…


I used sugru with a core of pennies. The base is too small, but I put the plug in a condom for cleanup and to pull it out if it goes too far. It’s small, though, and that sucks. I wouldn’t really recommend it, but it’s fun.

Reddit user

Get a thick toothbrush without a very rough rubbery surface and cut off the thin upper part with a kitchen knife. You might wanna use sandpaper to smoothen the edges. The shape of some toothbrushes ensures they stay in and since they are often covered with a wave-like pattern they can be more stimulating.

Furthermore, if the upper part is cut off you should be able to sit down. Unfortunately, they are rather thin but that’s the best thing I could come up with.



And here you have it – everything you need to know about homemade butt plugs and their safety!

As you can see, if you’re willing to get a bit creative, the sky is the limit when it comes to sex toys. 

But while there are plenty of ways to make your own butt plugs, I recommend you stay on the safer side and buy a cheap one from Lovehoney. 

It will save you the hassle, and you won’t need to deal with emergency visits to the ER for having problems with a butt plug during sex!

Dainis Graveris

Dainis Graveris

With over 2 year experience working in a local adult toy store Dainis has gathered quite a bit of experience about helping people find the best for their needs. He's also a top writer on Quora (7M views, 2.3K followers) and has written over 70+ guides on SexualAlpha. Read More

Got Questions? Ping me on Twitter.